(PLACER COUNTY, Calif.) On Tuesday, November 17 2026, Placer County Sheriff’s Office announced the arrest of Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice and daughter, Mary Fitzmaurice, in connection to a severed head found on September 28, 2022 in Todd Valley, Foresthill. The victim of the beheading was identified in January 2024 as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., husband to the now 75 year old Gwenn and 45 year old Mary.
The severed head was first discovered in a trash bag disposed of in Todd Valley. Due to the skull’s decomposition, victim identification was impossible at the time. Additionally, no missing person reports or homicides matched the crime or circumstances.
In 2022, the skull was sent to California State University, Chico where an estimated age and race profile was developed by forensic specialists. Experts also generated an illustration of the victim, which was used by law enforcement for identification among existing missing persons. Despite these efforts, identity confirmation of the victim continued to be unsuccessful.

Photo Credit: California State University, Chico / Preliminary illustration of Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr. developed by forensic specialists
Other early attempts to identify the victim included entering DNA from the skull into the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS). By January 2024, CODIS and all other law enforcement methods still yielded no conclusive results.
Investigators eventually transferred the DNA to Othram Labs, a facility specialising in genome sequencing. Othram’s genealogy testing was able to provide a genetic profile which aided law enforcement in identifying existing blood relatives. The FBI joined the investigation and together with Placer County Sheriff’s Office, began tracing a family lineage. Interviews and DNA samples were retrieved from the relatives that were traced.
In 2024, the beheaded victim was finally identified as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr. The victim, who was 73 years old at the time of the incident, was never reported missing. Evidence showed Fitzmaurice Jr. was last documented as living with his wife and daughter in Citrus Heights.
Sheriff Wayne Woo, shared information on the ongoing investigation during a press conference held by Placer County Sheriff’s Office.
Woo highlighted that the case remained unfamiliar to most due to the Mosquito Fire that was raging when the severed head was discovered.
After evidence revealed Fitzmaurice Jr. was last reported as living with his wife and daughter, the Sheriff’s Office launched an investigation into his wife, Gwenn, with support from the Citrus Heights police department.

Photo Credit: Placer County Sheriff’s Office / Mary Fitzmaurice (left), Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice (right)
“Through the investigation, we discovered that Gwenn and Mary had kept up the facade that Paul was still alive,” Woo shared. “In fact, they were still receiving Paul’s Social Security benefits and his CalPERS pension.”
Following the arrest of Mary and Gwenn, District Attorney Morgan Guyer shared the next steps for criminal prosecution.
“Mary has been booked on murder charges,” Guyer shared. “Gwenn has been booked on accomplice charges.”
Guyer revealed that Placer County is currently working on investigating whether further charges will be indicted for Mary and Gwenn.
The Sheriff’s Office shared that the body of the victim still remains undiscovered. Sheriff Woo offered that the lack of remains is likely linked to the ongoing benefits the perpetrators have been receiving on behalf of Fitzmaurice Jr.
“There’s still a lot of investigative work to be done, and I would be speculating on motive at this point.” Woo said.

Photo Credit: Hannah Runoff / The Sacramento Bee / Mary Fitzmaurice in custody in Placer County
The Sheriff stated there is no current indication of a connection between the victim’s Citrus Heights residency and the disposal of the severed head in Foresthill. Placer County is in the process of using evidence acquired from the home of Mary and Gwenn to establish an existing association.
When asked whether other relatives had expressed concern over the disappearance of Fitzmaurice Jr., Woo delivered the story Mary and Gwenn had been spreading.
“He was estranged from some of his blood relative family,” Woo said. “Those family members when we spoke to them had been told by the wife and the daughter that he was still alive and that he was suffering from some substance abuse issues, was being a recluse, and he would disappear for days at a time…”
Placer County Sheriff’s Office will provide updates as more investigation information becomes publicly available.
Updates on the Fitzmaurice Jr. case can be found on the Placer Sheriff’s Office facebook page and other social media sites.
To add to or correct any information in this report, please contact me at piper.a@lead4earth.org.
0
0
Comments