(MAUI, HI.) —Amid nonstop rains and unprecedented flooding across the island, the Mar. 20 City Council meeting opened with a palpable sense of urgency and unease. Several council members opted to participate via Zoom rather than risk traveling through the storm, underscoring the severity of the conditions. Despite the weather, a full agenda of pressing matters remained before the body.
Early in the meeting, however, the tone shifted when a ceremonial resolution honoring the 50th anniversary of Protect Kahoʻolawe ʻOhana was abruptly canceled at the request of Council Member Keani Rollins Fernandez. The decision to pull the recognition — intended to celebrate the organization’s decades of cultural and environmental stewardship — raised concerns among observers and set a tense tone for the proceedings that followed.
Photo Credit: Maui County YouTube
The council also moved forward with two key executive appointments, confirming Jaclyn Mc Takura as Planning Director in an 8-0 vote and Margaret Y. Ellis as Director of Human Concerns in a narrower 6-2 decision. Ellis’ appointment drew questions from council members and testifiers regarding her residency status and ties to the Maui community. Support for Mc Takura was strong.
“Jaclyn brings more than 25 years of integrity and public service to this role,” says Eva Blumenstein, speaking in favor of the appointment. “She’s a proactive problem-solver who understands the real challenges we face, from water supply constraints to the need for genuine community engagement in planning decisions.”
Although Mc Takura ultimately received unanimous approval, Ellis’ nomination was not without criticism. One testifier, identified as Sam, urged the council to delay confirmation until broader concerns within the Planning Department were addressed.
“I’m asking the council not to approve this appointment until we address the serious breakdown between Planning and Public Works,” he testifies. “Environmental and public safety conditions under SMA law cannot continue to be dismissed.”
Photo Credit: Maui County YouTube
While those concerns were directed at departmental operations rather than Ellis personally, the testimony underscored ongoing public unease surrounding land-use oversight and interdepartmental accountability.
Numerous budget amendments and ordinances were passed rapidly, many advancing after only a first or second reading and without prior committee deliberation. The pace of these approvals drew criticism from Council Member Batagan, who argued that the expedited process limited transparency and cut out the need for public participation.
Public testimony echoed these concerns, alleging a lack of transparency in SMA permit approvals, potential conflicts of interest involving high-profile developers such as Greg Brown, an issue raised in previous council meetings and ongoing failures in interdepartmental coordination related to environmental and public safety conditions.
While the council gratefully accepted a significant donation of fire trucks, a gesture that underscored meaningful community support and partnership — the broader tone of the meeting reflected a governing body that was looking to pass many bills and amendments without much public discourse.
Numerous measures advancing swiftly without much deliberation prompted concerns from some members and testifiers about transparency and public engagement.
On matters such as land use, development oversight, and executive appointments, the pace of decision-making left lingering questions about sufficient scrutiny and community input. As the council moves forward, the meeting served as a reminder of the ongoing tension between administrative efficiency and the public’s expectation for openness, accountability, and thoughtful debate in shaping Maui’s future.
To add to or correct any information in this report, please contact me at allyson.w@lead4earth.org and leave a comment below.
1
0
Comments