(CITRUS HEIGHTS, Calif.) — Citrus Heights City Council members debated whether the city should change how written public comments are presented during council meetings, raising questions about public access, accessibility and the time required to read large volumes of submissions.
OpGov.News reports the discussion during the Nov. 10 meeting followed a request from Mayor MariJane Lopez-Taff, seconded by Councilmember Tim Schaefer, at the Aug. 26 meeting to revisit the city’s written public comment procedures.
Under the current policy, residents can submit written comments online or by email by 4 p.m. on the day of a meeting. The comments are distributed to all council members and become part of the public record but are not read aloud during the meeting.
Residents also can participate in person or remotely through Zoom.
City Clerk Amy Van explained that the city reviewed procedures in other jurisdictions, including Folsom, Rancho Cordova, Elk Grove and West Sacramento, where written comments also are not routinely read aloud.
The issue prompted differing views among council members.

Photo Credit: Metro Cable 14 / Citrus Heights Mayor MariJane Lopez-Taff argued that written public comments should continue to be read aloud during City Council meetings, citing public access and accessibility concerns.
Mayor Lopez-Taff maintained that written comments should continue to be read during meetings, regardless of how other cities handle them. She cited a previous meeting that generated approximately 42 comments expressing similar views, describing the volume as an unusual occurrence rather than a recurring problem.
“I maintain that we should read all of our public comments regardless of what our neighbors do,” Lopez-Taff said. “Citrus Heights has always remained independent in our approach to how we communicate to the public. I think our public deserves [that].”
She also raised accessibility concerns, noting that residents with visual impairments may depend on comments being read aloud to understand what others have submitted.
“I particularly have a vision-impaired parent, and I know that if she were a resident of our city, she would need the comments read aloud,” Lopez-Taff said.
Vice Mayor Porsche Middleton and Councilmember Dr. Jayna Karpinski-Costa supported the existing practice, citing concerns that reading large numbers of repetitive submissions could consume meeting time without adding substantially different information.

Photo Credit: Metro Cable 14 / Citrus Heights Vice Mayor Porsche Middleton supported the city’s current written public comment policy, raising concerns about the time required to read large numbers of similar submissions aloud.
Middleton questioned the value of reading numerous form letters with identical wording. “I think we can say, Hey, I got 100 of these and all say this right here,” she said.
Karpinski-Costa agreed with the vice mayor, saying, “The purpose of public comment is to let us know what they think about an item. Not to let the world know.”
Councilmember Tim Schaefer said he agreed with Middleton and Karpinski-Costa.
Councilmember Kelsey Nelson expressed mixed views, saying she saw value in reading public comments during meetings but also understood concerns about lengthy stacks of form letters.
Council members also discussed whether the city could acknowledge receiving multiple similar submissions without reading each one individually.
Lopez-Taff said the discussion reinforced the importance of ensuring residents know their comments are received and considered. She encouraged residents seeking a response from council members to provide contact information with their submissions so officials have an opportunity to respond.
After hearing from colleagues, Lopez-Taff indicated support for maintaining the city's existing procedures. No changes were directed during the discussion.
Under the current process, written comments submitted by the 4 p.m. deadline are forwarded to council members and retained as part of the public record. Residents may also address the council in person or through Zoom, with speakers generally limited to three minutes.
Submit Citrus Heights story tips and ideas to piper.a@lead4earth.org. Submit Sacramento tips and story ideas to Sarah Denos at sarahkdenos@gmail.com.
0
0
Comments